by Walter Brasch
AR Senior Correspondent
Nov. 24, 2011
DID PENN STATE TRUSTEES VIOLATE STATE LAW?
STATE COLLEGE, Pa. -- The Penn State Board of Trustees may have violated state law several times by its failure to publicly announce meetings and reveal how it handled the firing of Coach Joe Paterno.
However, these violations may be the least of the Board's worries as it scrambles to reduce fall-out from the scandal that began with revelations that an assistant football coach may be a serial child molester, and that the university may have been negligent.
The state's Sunshine Act [65 Pa C S A 701 et seq] requires all public bodies to publish notices at least 24 hours before their meetings. The purpose is to eliminate secret meetings. Penn State, a private university, which received $279 million from the Commonwealth for its 2011-2012 budget, is bound by the Sunshine Act.
A public notice did appear in the Centre Daily Times, Penn State College's hometown newspaper, three days before a regularly-scheduled board meeting on Friday Nov. 11. But the Trustees were caught flat-footed the week before by what eventually turned into the largest scandal in its history. These are events the Trustees should have been aware of for at least two years; certainly, the Board should have known there was a problem when the Harrisburg Patriot-News broke a story in March that the Grand Jury was investigating former defensive coordinator Jerry Sandusky.
But, based upon Board incompetence, there wasn't even a crisis management plan in place when Sandusky was arrested Nov. 5, and Athletic Director Tim Curley; and Gary Schultz, senior vice-president of finance and administration, were charged with perjury and failure to report a crime to police. The Trustees allowed Curley to take an administrative leave, and Schultz to return to retirement. Schultz, who had worked for Penn State for 40 years, had retired in 2009, but had been brought back on an interim basis in July. Both Curley's and Schultz's decisions were probably influenced by the Board demands.
During the two weeks, beginning Nov. 5, the Board had conference calls, executive sessions, and emergency meetings, all without public notice.
Conference calls involving a quorum without public notice aren't allowed. At least one such conference call was conducted on Saturday, Nov. 5. A meeting by telephone is just as illegal as a meeting with all persons at a table if it isn't publicly announced.
Several emergency meetings were held the next few days. The Sunshine Act allows emergency meetings. The Trustees conducted meetings Sunday, Nov. 6, Monday, Nov. 7, and Wednesday, Nov. 9. By law, an emergency meeting can be called, without public notice, only for "the purpose of dealing with a real or potential emergency involving a clear and present danger to life or property." [65 Pa.C.S.A A7703]
Even in the wildest stretch of that definition, there was no clear and present danger. That occurred years ago when the university didn't contact police to report the actions of a man believed to be a child molester.
Executive sessions to discuss personnel issues and some other items are allowed - if they are announced at public meetings "immediately prior or subsequent to the executive session." [65 Pa.C.S.S. A7708(b)] But, they were not.
About 10 p.m., Nov. 9, following an emergency meeting, Board vice-chair John P. Surma, flanked by 21 of the 31 trustees, publicly announced it had fired Paterno and accepted the forced resignation of PSU president Graham Spanier. Surma told the media the decision about Paterno was unanimous, thus indicating a vote was done in secret and not under public scrutiny as required.
Because Spanier was under a long-term contract, the Trustees would also have been expected to have to vote to formally accept his resignation.
The Trustees also violated Paterno's rights under law. It's doubtful the Board members, most of them in corporate business, even care. How they handled Paterno's firing is indicative of their little regard for employee rights and due process. Paterno had previously said he would retire at the end of the season, since he believed, "the Board of Trustees should not spend a single minute discussing my status. They have far more important matters to address. I want to make this as easy for them as I possibly can." The Trustees, undoubtedly, believed firing Paterno immediately would take heat off the university. Again, it was wrong.
Although executive sessions may be conducted in private, the Sunshine Act requires that "individual employees or appointees whose rights could be adversely affected may request, in writing, that the matter or matters be discussed at an open meeting." [65 Pa.C.S.A. A7708(a)(1)] Paterno was not contacted by the Board prior to termination, either to request to be heard or to request an open meeting. Paterno was informed of his termination by a hand-delivered letter that demanded he place a phone call to a board member. There was no indication in that letter of what the Board's decision was.
Violating the law could result in invalidating decisions made at those meetings, and penalties of $1,000 for each violation; until September, the penalty had been a paltry $100. But here's a nice twist. The Trustees probably don't care.
A district attorney must approve prosecution for Sunshine Act violations. Although the Pennsylvania Newspaper Association (PNA) receives about 1,000 inquiries each year about what may be Sunshine Act and Right-to-Know law violations, "it's rare for criminal prosecutions of the Sunshine Act," according to Melissa Melewsky, media law council for the PNA. Civil actions by individuals are likewise difficult to pursue because of significant costs.
Here's another surprise. Because of heavy lobbying to the legislature, whose members are feasted at one home game a year and can also receive comp football tickets to other home football games, Penn State is not bound by the state's Right-to-Know law. This means that innumerable records, including minutes of all meetings - both public and those that are illegal under the Sunshine Act - can still be secret.
Here's something not so surprising, however. Penn State's Public Affairs office punted all questions to the Board. The Board arrogantly has refused to answer both verbal and written questions. However, possibly using public funds, it did hire a PR firm to handle crisis management issues. We won't know the cost - that's something it doesn't have to tell the taxpayers.
Assisting on this story was Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel of the Pennsylvania Newspaper Association. Walter Brasch, as president of both the Keystone chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists and Pennsylvania Press Club, was active in fighting for a stronger Right-to-Know law and enforcement of the Sunshine Act. He is an award-winning syndicated columnist and retired university professor. His latest book is Before the First Snow, a mystery/thriller set in Pennsylvania.]
The latest book from AR Senior Correspondent Dr. Walter M. Brasch is Before the First Snow: Stories from the Revolution, published by Greeley & Stone. You can see his other work and commentary at www.walterbrasch.com, www.walterbrasch.blogspot.com, on Facebook at www.facebook.com/walterbrasch, and on YouTube at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v3DE6cC4zHnFAY