Vol. 22, No. 5,514 - The American Reporter - September 7, 2016

by Randolph T. Holhut
American Reporter Correspondent
Dummerston, Vt.
January 7, 2011
On Native Ground

Back to home page

Printable version of this story

DUMMERSTON, Vt. -- One of the bedrock tenets of conservatism is the idea of American Exceptionalism - that the United States is the greatest nation in the world.

Yes, this nation has been successful at exporting the idea of represenative democracy around the world. Nearly two-thirds of the world's population today live in societies where traditional American civic values are upheld.

The American Idea - the idea of a nation governed by a representative democracy, a nation of laws and not men, a nation where every person has the right to "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness" - is what makes our nation exceptional. That idea has never been completely realized for all Americans, but that is the idea other nations sought to emulate.

These are ideas that come from the age that conservatives love to hate, the Enlightenment.

The men who drafted the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution believed in the idea that human affairs should be guided by rationality, rather than by faith and superstition. They believed in the power of freedom, democracy and human reason to change society and liberate the individual from arbitrary authority. And they got those ideas from men such as Hobbes, Locke. Spinoza, Voltaire, Rousseau and Hume.

That's the exceptionalism that we celebrate in the American Idea. But you'll never hear conservatives credit the great philosophers of the Age of Enlightenment for shaping the views of Jefferson, Hamilton, Franklin and Madison. And you'll never hear today's conservatives champion reason and rationality as the bedrock of our democracy. If anything, they are the people doing everything they can to destroy reason and rationality.

It doesn't take much thought to wave a flag and shout "We're Number One!" But even a cursory glance at where our nation stands in 2011 shows that our nation isn't all that exceptional - at least in the things that matter.

Spend some time on nationmaster.com, a wonderful online data base that shows where countries rank in various socio-economic categories, and the numbers don't back up the conservative image of the shining city on a hill:

  • In education, our high school students rank 14th in scientific literacy, 15th in reading literacy and 18th in mathematical literacy.

  • We spend more on health care than any other nation in the world, yet only rank 47th in overall life expectancy.

  • More than 50 million Americans still lack health insurance - something that is a right, rather than a privilege, for the citizens in every other advanced nation in the world.

  • We have the largest and most technologically powerful economy in the world, yet we also have the most unequal distribution of wealth of any industrialized nation.

  • One in eight Americans are on food stamps. One in four American children live in poverty. Nearly one in five Americans are either out of work, working part-time because they can't find a full-time job or have given up looking for work altogether.

  • We're the country that invented the Internet, yet the United States ranks 16th in per capita broadband access and 15th in broadband speed (and my state, Vermont, is near the bottom in both categories).

  • Of the 15 tallest buildings in the world, six of them are in China - and China will soon pass the United States as the country with the most buildings on the world's 100 tallest list.

  • Our national infrastructure is crumbling, and too many Americans would rather see tax cuts than bridges that don't collapse or water mains that don't burst.

  • While other nations are building high-speed trains, our passenger rail network is a joke.

So, what are we No. 1 in?

Well, we spend more on our military then every other nation in the world - friend and foe, alike - combined. And U.S. military personnel are garrisoned in more nations than any other nation's armed forces.

    We have more of our population in prison than any other nation in the world, and we are the only industrialized democracy that still executes prisoners.

    In short, conservatives love to talk about the greatness of America, but consistently fail to put their money where their mouths are.

    We can't be an exceptional nation when so many Americans are out of work, and out of luck, while the wealthiest Americans grow even more wealthy.

    We can't be an exceptional nation if our educational system lags behind the rest of the world, and religious superstition is allowed to trump science in our classrooms.

    We can't be an exceptional nation if we refuse to spend money for the common good, while lavishing money on the wealthy and the military-industrial complex.

    For our nation to become truly exceptional, we need to stop being an empire with bases and soldiers scattered all over the globe.

    We need to have a nation that provides for the general welfare and invests in the public sphere. We need a democracy that isn't sold to the highest bidder. We need a free press that isn't shackled by corporate interests.

    We need an economy that puts the needs of people and the planet ahead of profit. We need an educational system that produces creative, thoughtful citizens.

    Most of all, we need to give up the notion that we are the most awesome nation on earth until that day comes when we can move up on all those lists of social, economic and medical well-being and once again stand at the top.

    AR Chief of Correspondents Randolph T. Holhut has been a journalist in New England for more than 30 years. He edited "The George Seldes Reader" (Barricade Books). He can be reached at randyholhut@yahoo.com.

    Copyright 2016 Joe Shea The American Reporter. All Rights Reserved.

    Site Meter